The Lost Garden, by Katharine Swartz
You may be surprised (nay, perhaps shocked) at how little I read when traveling. All those flights, train trips, early evenings – one would think I’d be in book heaven…but afraid not. I gaze out at the scenery during train journeys holding my book (or kindle) unopened. I find myself catching up on missed movies during long flights and, as a typically tired tourist (all that walking, exploring, eating, navigating and translating) I fall asleep as soon as my head hits the pillow. So my reading falls by the wayside.
I wanted an easy-going book for this most recent trip. Nothing too complicated with multiplying characters or, even worse, a family tree to keep straight. I knew while in Switzerland, I would be happily distracted and pleasantly tired. I would only be reading in short bits and pieces.
I’d been saving the The Lost Garden just for this trip. I eagerly awaited this historical novel of a hidden garden with secrets, a dual time-line (present day and just after WWII) and set in rural England. (I know, I’m boringly quite predictable.)
It also held charm because it brought to mind The Secret Garden one of my all-time favorite and cherished children’s books.
The Lost Garden is both a mystery and family saga set at Bower House, on the edge of a village church property with a hidden walled garden. In 1919, nineteen-year-old Eleanor Sanderson is grieving the death of her brother so her father hires a young gardener, Jack to restore the walled garden to comfort her. Eleanor falls for Jack especially once he reveals the garden to her. (I won’t give away the special garden he created – just know it’s magical.) Problems arise, secrets are kept and the garden is at the center of it all.
In the present day, Marin Ellis has taken on the custody of her sulky 15 year old half-sister, Rebecca. They move to Bower house to try and start a new life for themselves. They, too, are grieving the sudden accidental death of their parents. When Rebecca shows a spark of interest in the now decrepit walled garden, Marin hires Joss, a local gardener to help them restore the garden. Together, they uncover the garden’s past and its secrets – and again friendships and romance evolve around the lost garden.
I found the characters authentic and the setting just so darn dreamy (I want my own secret garden…). For those readers who want a fast moving plot and high drama – this is not a book for you, as The Lost Garden moves gently and slowly along. I found myself living with its characters, breathing in the rooms of the house and seeing the garden transformed in both time periods.
A purely pleasant read for total escape to a magical secret garden — some times that’s all you need.
Digital review copy provided by Lion Fiction via NetGalley.
Louise Penny – in person
Last night I went to an author event at Keplers Books in Menlo Park (a great bookstore)…but this was not just any author event – it was LOUISE PENNY — author of the Chief Inpsector Gamache series based in the fictional village of Three Pines outside of Montreal. If you don’t know of Louise Penny it is advised that you immediately get yourself to a bookstore or library and get your hands on her first book, Still Life. You’ll thank me later, or maybe not — because there is a warning – you won’t be able to wait for the next book in the series to come into the library, and you will happily spend your hard-earned dollars on the next book … and the next.
Here’s some photos from the event.
Ms. Penny is just as I imagined her – warm, funny, self-deprecating, smart, wise, gracious and very very real. I want to be her new best friend – (but not in a creepy stalking kind of way).
I also got this – see what I mean about spending your money?
Her new book – signed. I started it last night and once I’ve finished I will give it away to any Book Barmy reader who can answer the following question:
What gift did Ms. Penny receive last night from an adoring fan? (And not from me, an originally from Canada fan…)
Submit your answers in the comments section and I’ll announce the winner in a future post.
Meanwhile – I’m leaving now to return to Three Pines, the bistro, Ruth and her duck…I know you’ll understand.
N.B. If more than one reader has the correct answer, trustworthy husband (he was an Eagle Scout you know) will pick the name at random.
Memoirs as Salvation
~~First an apology for the radio silence. I’ve been neglecting Book Barmy lately. Last minute travel preparations dominate right now, as we prepare to leave on a grand trip next week. As a result, my reading has dwindled to a few pages at night- (sometimes the same pages from the night before) until I can’t keep my eyes open. Stay tuned for more on our travel excitement in an upcoming post. ~~
What is it about memoirs? I gravitate toward them in anxious times and decided it was because I’m a bit of a guilty voyeur combined with a dash of schadenfreude. I seem to gain solace from dipping into the disastrous lives of others. So when I came across this wonderful Mary Karr essay HERE , I knew I had a chum — another memoir lover out there.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Then there’s the infamous Angela’s Ashes by Frank McCourt. I have a fond memory of finding this book in a little bookshop in Dublin and reading it cover to cover on the flight home. During the flight, as I was hunkered into this book, the attendant brought me my meal and commented on what I was reading — I confessed I felt guilty eating because poor Frank and his family hadn’t had enough food for days.
From the opening of Mr. McCourt’s autobiography:
When I look back on my childhood I wonder how I managed to survive at all. It was, of course, a miserable childhood: the happy childhood is hardly worth your while. Worse than the ordinary miserable childhood is the miserable Irish childhood, and worse yet is the miserable Irish Catholic childhood.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
One of my all time favorites is Eat Pray Love, by Elizabeth Gilbert. Read this memoir for it’s depiction of a trip of a lifetime and Ms. Gilbert’s personal journey. Rediscovering joy, peace and love while gaining friends, insights and few extra pounds along the way. It’s really not as sappy as I just made it sound – honestly.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
And now for something similar yet completely different … Running with Scissors by Augusten Burroughs. Once again we witness a nightmarish youth and the reparations, but in this case Mr. Burroughs tells his tale in such a way that it is both entertaining and outrageous. So entertaining, in fact that some studio attempted to make a film based on the book. Just terrible, give it a miss – the film that is – not the book.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
I was recently reminded of the classic Testament of Youth – an autobiography of a independent woman who volunteers as a nurse during WWI. I missed many a wild club scene evening buried in its pages back in the 80’s. It’s been adapted into what looks to be a promising film (trailer HERE).
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
The other evening I started this unique memoir. Grieving over the unexpected death of her father, Helen MacDonald rediscovers her love of falconry with a prickly and murderous goshawk — named Mabel. I’m only a few chapters in and it’s riveting (at least for as long as I’m able to stay awake these recent nights).
Not forgetting the other memoirs here on Book Barmy –THIS or THIS
What are your favorite memoirs or autobiographies?
The Signature of All Things by Elizabeth Gilbert
I was entranced by this book — just holding the beautiful hardback edition, with its botanical illustrations on the front and back flyleaves, gave me a little thrill. I was especially hooked by the storyline which follows a 19th century female botanist. I’ve long been fascinated with the early botanical illustrators who ventured into harsh climes to painstakingly draw and record plant specimens before the advent of photography. Add to this that I savored Ms. Gilbert’s Eat, Pray, Love — both the book and the film. So I was set – that magical feeling of embarking into a book that holds great promise.
The Signature of All Things starts with the turn of the century birth of Alma Whittaker in January of 1800 to unorthodox and wealthy Philadelphia parents. On the first page we are lead back into Alma’s father’s beginnings — with this wonderful line:
How her father came to be in possession of such great wealth is a story worth telling here, while we wait for the girl to grow up and catch our interest again.
And so we learn of the world-spanning exploits of Henry Whittaker, thief turned botanist, in the late 1700s, where money follows Alma’s father around like a small, excited dog.
When we do meet Alma Whittaker some 50 pages in, she is being tutored by her parents in languages, acute observation and critical thought — they expect her, from a young age, to actively participate in their glittering intellectual dinner parties. She is cocooned within their estate — White Acres and the plant world — so beloved by her father. There is even a large indoor botanical garden patterned after George III’s own design.
Alma learned to tell time by the opening and closing of flowers. At five o’clock in the morning, she noticed, the goatsbeard petals always unfolded. At six o’clock, the daisies and globeflowers opened. When the clock struck seven, the dandelions would bloom. At eight o’clock, it was the scarlet pimpernel’s turn…
But, before long, Alma has descended into a prematurely sad, old woman. She is someone whose intellectual life is more important than any emotional one — she had too much to accomplish.
Whenever a beam of light shone through one of the tall, wavy-glassed windows, Alma would turn her face up toward it, like a tropical vine in one of her father’s botanical forcing houses, wishing to climb her way out.
Alma becomes an expert on mosses – her own botanical choice – as no one had ever studied their miniature ecosystems in depth. Alma publishes several highly-regarded botanical volumes on mosses during her years.
Moss grows where nothing else can grow. It grows on bricks. It grows on tree bark and roofing slate. It grows in the Arctic Circle and in the balmiest topics …moss is the first sign of botanic life to reappear on land that has been burned or otherwise stripped down to barrenness. The only thing moss needs is time, and it was beginning to appear to Alma that the world had plenty of time of offer.
Eventually Ambrose, an androgynous orchid illustrator, captivates her with his words and his art – and so she marries him — but alas, no romance for Alma.
For many years (even before Ambrose) Alma has found her sexual pleasure in a closet by herself – and we are given great detail of her “self-pleasuring” exploits. (Just as with the one and only porn film I watched, it quickly becomes painfully absurd.)
Alma lives well into her 9th decade, and her adventures, and those of her father, weave together the development of evolutionary thought during the mid-1800s. We learn how Captain Cook influenced Charles Darwin and we even get to meet A.R. Wallace who posited a theory of biodiversity concurrent with Darwin’s. Alma, too, comes upon her own theory of evolution via her moss studies, but Darwin beats everyone to the punch and garners all the fame. Ms. Gilbert fascinates in telling of these historical scientific discoveries, exploits and follies.
In an interview, Ms. Gilbert tells of years doing research and a 70-page outline. This exhaustive research and hard writing work clearly shines through in The Signature of All Things.
Where the novel falters is in the secondary characters who are introduced, one per chapter, as if even Ms. Gilbert was getting bored with her story and wanted new players. Alma’s adopted sister Prudence and their friend, Retta are meant to contrast with Alma’s cerebral character — but I found them unbelievable. The novel becomes a little un-tethered (as does Alma) once she leaves White Acres for Tahiti and Amsterdam where the complicated and dramatic relationships feel a bit contrived.
I found the novel at times strikingly beautiful — there is some jeweled writing — but also at time, tedious. Even though I merely scanned more than a few pages, I had to keep reading through to the end– as Alma’s story is ultimately fascinating and heartrending.
N.B. The title of the book refers to the theory that all life contains a divine code which was put forth by 16th century botanist, Jacob Boehme in his book De Signatura Rerum (The Signature of All Things).
Can Reading Make You Happier?
You may remember that I read and reviewed The Novel Cure, wherein I discovered my perfect second-half-of-life career choice – Bibliotherapist.
Here’s a wonderful New Yorker article that delves further into this concept.
From the article:
Bibliotherapy is a very broad term for the ancient practice of encouraging reading for therapeutic effect. The first use of the term is usually dated to a jaunty 1916 article in The Atlantic Monthly, “A Literary Clinic.” In it, the author describes stumbling upon a “bibliopathic institute” run by an acquaintance, Bagster, in the basement of his church, from where he dispenses reading recommendations with healing value. “Bibliotherapy is…a new science,” Bagster explains. “A book may be a stimulant or a sedative or an irritant or a soporific. The point is that it must do something to you, and you ought to know what it is. A book may be of the nature of a soothing syrup or it may be of the nature of a mustard plaster.”
And then there’s this:
For all avid readers who have been self-medicating with great books their entire lives, it comes as no surprise that reading books can be good for your mental health and your relationships with others, but exactly why and how is now becoming clearer, thanks to new research on reading’s effects on the brain.
I haven’t secretly fist-pumped such information since they proved the scientific health benefits of a glass of red wine.
Turns out the authors of The Novel Cure (Berthoud and Elderkin) practice their Bibliotherapy through The School of Life, founded by one of my favorite authors, Alain de Bottom. His book The Art of Travel is a beautiful volume of essays to be carefully savored one delicious essay at a time.
So the Book Barmy Bibliotheraphy Practice doors are officially open.
Be my guinea pigs, send me your problem or issue either via comments or email — and I’ll recommend a book or two to help you get through it.
No charge.
Meanwhile, I’m in the middle of this – stay tuned…
The Bookstore Mouse by Peggy Christian
Just next door to the bookstore where I work/volunteer, there’s a children’s arts center with afternoon classes. When class is over the children often run (with parents trailing behind) into the store and quickly gravitate to our special children’s room/play area (click to see full size).
The parents can then, while keeping an eye on the little ones, slip over to the cafe and grab a coffee (they also sell wine and beer but I’ve never seen any parental indulgence –strong folks these parents).
Over the months, I’ve formed a friendship with one little girl who comes in every week after art class and her mom lets her buy a book or two. I’ll call her Penny because she is just as bright as a penny (no real names or photo for obvious reasons). Penny is a sturdy little girl, cowboy boots, a big wide grin, bangs I suspect she chops at herself, and an eclectic sense of colorful mismatched clothes. One can tell she must be a handful for parents and teachers alike — that combustive combination of open intelligence, imagination, impatience and enviable self-confidence – I liked her instantly.
Almost every week, she’ll find me in the store, just to say hello and to talk about things – what she did in art class (she once made me an origami bird), the books she’s reading, the books I’m shelving — Penny just loves to talk. But no idle chatter for Penny, she wants to know things — her conversations are real and her questions intense. Mostly we talk about books while her poor mother grabs a to-go coffee from the cafe. One week I pressed Blueberries for Sal into her hands promising her she would love it – she did. She can’t wait to read Harry Potter, but bemoans that she is still to young to read “such big books”.
++++++++++++++++++++++
One day she brought this little book up to the register to purchase. Penny and I agreed it was a great find (the children’s books are not organized in any way, so the search is half the fun) and that it looked to be a very good book. I asked her to tell me about it once she’d read it because, of course, I love stories about bookstores and books.
A couple weeks later Penny brought her book back and handed it me…saying “You can borrow this to read yourself. My Dad helped me, we had to look up lots of the words, but I think you will really like it – it’s soooooooo good, but I want it back, please, when you’re done.”
I know, I know, let’s have a collective moment of awwwww. I especially like that she was quite firm — SHE WANTS HER BOOK BACK – a fellow book hoarder in the making.
So during this week I read The Bookstore Mouse.
It’s the story of a mouse named Cervantes who lives in a bookstore and actually survives physically and emotionally on words – by eating them out of cookbooks, history books, novels. This little mouse has an impressive knowledge of words because the dictionary is his favorite book.
The words are typeset in differing fonts to show their meanings — anger, hunger, fright – as so…
One day Cervantes, trying to escape the bookstore cat, jumps into a book and gets pulled into a story about a scribe who has to save a village from a dragon. The scribe has trouble finding the right words and Cervantes (and the child reading the story) tries to fill in just the right word. During the story they meet a giant who makes up very big words that mean nothing and we learn that big words can get in the way — smaller words often have more meaning.
I can see why Penny (and her Dad) had to look up words – here’s a sample of some of vocabulary I had to look up: prodigious, infandous, cacography — and then there are the made up words like nigmenog, whosits.
There is wordplay meant for very clever readers or adults. For example, the dragon is appropriately named Censor. Then there are underline worthy quotes such as this:
A page of print is like a secret passage that leads you to worlds so far away, you cannot imagine them until the magic of reading carries you there.
This is a tale where the words are the main character and these words need untangling and then become weapons, power and protection. This book will not only improve a young vocabulary, but deserves to be read aloud (while stopping to look up words together) with a bright young person in your life
Thank you Penny.